Q:
Blacks and whites are 99% genetically identical so race is
meaningless.
A: To
answer this let's check out what biological scientist Michael
Rienzi had to say in an article published
in, American Renaissance in December 2000:
Although
it is true that human populations share roughly 99.9% of their
genes, it also true that humans share over 98% of their genes with
chimpanzees, and [85%
to 90% with mice]. Many of these genes produce basic body
structures all mammals have in common; differences between organisms
are caused by very small genetic differences.
Current evidence suggests that all the sex
differences between men and women are the result of just one genetic
difference-one gene (the testes determining factor) out of an
estimated 50,000-100,000! This would mean men and women are 99.998
to 99.999% genetically identical, yet no one suggests that sex is a
mere "social construct." In like manner, the genetic
differences between humans and chimpanzees, which no one denies, can
be described as 12 to 20 times the genetic differences between
racial groups.
Tiny genetic differences can have a huge
phenotypic consequences because genes are ordered in a hierarchal
fashion. Some genes are "master genes," and control the
expression of a number of other genes, each of which may further
control several other genes. Also, the expression of each gene is
controlled by regions called "promoters" and
"enhancers," usually located in front of the functional
part of the genes. A small change in the promoter region of gene
"X" can alter it's expression. X may control genes A, B,
C, D, E, F. Gene A in turn may control it's own set of genes. Even
if all of the genes other than "X" are identical between
two groups, the one difference in "X" would be sufficient
to produce large group differences.
It is not the quantity of genetic
difference that is important, but the nature of the differences:
which genes are different, in what ways they differ, and the
consequences of these differences. Breeds of dogs are analogous to
human races. It is likely that different breeds are as close
genetically as different races of humans, but there is no doubt that
subtle variations result in significant differences in appearance,
intelligence, and behavior.
It is also worth considering that a
butterfly and the caterpillar from which it developed are 100%
genetically identical! These genes do not change; the enormous
differences between caterpillar and butterfly result from the
activation of different genes at different times. This should give
some pause to those who think a 0.1% difference in tens of thousands
of humans genes "makes no difference."
(from Race is a Myth?, p. 1)
BACK
|